Integrated Child Credit
Published on 12 January 2004
LITRG response for the Social Security Committee's Inquiry into Integrated Child Credit - 29 September 2000
Summary
- The new tax credits will successfully reduce child poverty only if they are clear and simple and so encourage full take-up. Much of the innate complexity of the Working Families Tax Credit (WFTC) stems from its not having been integrated with the tax system, so that, despite having been re-named a tax credit, it essentially remains a benefit. By contrast the Children’s Tax Credit (CTC) is essentially a tax credit. Merging them as they stand with other income related benefits in what purports to be a seamless web in order to form the new tax credits is likely to be a recipe for confusion, low take-up, fraud and error. On any basis it appears that the computer systems to support a fully integrated system will not be available until 2006, three years later than the new tax credits are due to be introduced.
- The additional take-up of WFTC over those drawing Family Credit is less than half the estimated increase. The cause of the shortfall is likely largely to be the complexity of the scheme. Some of our proposals for simplifying it for the selfemployed have at last been accepted. But there remain large areas where differences between WFTC and income tax remain, leading to confusion for claimants and a greater risk of fraud and error. This is compounded by outdated and inaccessible legislation. The underlying law for the new tax credits should be drafted from scratch, in accordance with modern drafting techniques, so that it is accessible for claimants’ advisers.
- The CTC is also very complex for what is essentially a simple mechanism and its interaction with the WFTC has not been worked through or explained. One reason stems from the failure of the Inland Revenue to consult the professional bodies. Such consultation is essential if the new tax credits are to be effective. The Revenue may also have failed to reach all those potentially entitled to the CTC by failing to consult benefit records. Effective joining up between the Inland Revenue and ONE is essential if the new tax credits are to deliver the Government’s policy objectives.
- Both the WFTC and the CTC muddle up the family and the individual in the basis of assessment. There must be a consistent basis for the new tax credits – probably the family should be the unit.
- Disability issues have so far been given a poor second place in the development of the tax credits and take-up of the Disabled Person’s Tax Credit (DPTC) has been very disappointing. The needs of the disabled must be given priority in the work on the new tax credits.
- So far, Housing Benefit (HB) (and Council Tax Benefit (CTB)) and tax credits have been considered in isolation from each other, leading to confusion in both policy and administration. Changes to HB and CTB must be tied in with the development of the new tax credits along the lines recommended by the Social Security Committee in its Sixth Report. The aim of making work pay and of providing employment opportunities for all will be furthered only if action is systematically taken looking across all the income related benefits and tax credits.
To open the file click below:
LITRG response
(12-01-2004)
Tax guides
Introduction to the tax system How do I work out my tax? What income is taxable? What tax allowances am I entitled to? What tax rates apply to me? How is my tax collected? What if I cannot pay my tax bill? Do I need to complete a tax return? Self Assessment: understanding the basics What is Simple Assessment? How do I claim tax back? How do I claim back tax I have overpaid through PAYE on wages or pensions? How do I claim back tax if I complete a tax return? How do I claim back tax if I am taxed under the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS)? How do I claim back tax on savings income? How do I claim a marriage allowance refund? How do I claim back tax on a payment protection insurance (PPI) pay-out? Should I use a tax refund company? What is National Insurance? How do I get a National Insurance number? What are Specified Adult Childcare credits? What is Scottish income tax? What is devolution? Do I have to pay Scottish income tax? How does Scottish income tax work? What is Welsh income tax? Do I have to pay Welsh income tax? Do I have to join a pension scheme? Tax relief on your pension contributions HMRC digital services Enquiries, penalties, appeals, complaints and debt Enquiries How to survive an enquiry by HMRC Tax penalties Tax appeals Alternative Dispute Resolution How do I complain to HMRC? What if I cannot pay my tax bill? What if I have a tax credits overpayment?
Am I employed, self-employed, both or neither? Working through a limited company What is the national minimum wage? How do I work out my tax? What income is taxable? What tax allowances am I entitled to? What tax rates apply to me? How is my tax collected? How is tax collected on taxable state benefits? How do I check my coding notice? Do I need to complete a tax return? What tax do I pay on redundancy payments? Termination payments on leaving the armed forces Employment benefits and expenses What are benefits-in-kind? What payments and benefits are non taxable? What if I incur expenses in relation to my job? What travel expenses can I claim? What if I use my own car for business purposes? Payroll giving Allowances and expenses paid to armed forces personnel and deductions from their income Pensions and employees What is automatic enrolment for employees? What National Insurance do I pay as an employee? How do I repay my student loan? What if I do not pay enough tax? What if I pay too much tax? What if I work abroad temporarily? What if I am in the armed forces and work overseas? First time workers Apprenticeships
Am I employed, self-employed, both, or neither? How do I register for tax and National Insurance? What business records should I keep? Working out profits, losses and capital allowances When do I make Self Assessment payments and file my tax return? How do I pay tax on self-employed income? What tax allowances am I entitled to? What is the trading allowance? What National Insurance do I pay if I am self-employed? What is the Construction Industry Scheme (CIS)? Tax checks for taxi, private hire and scrap metal licences How do I work out my profits for universal credit? Do I have to pay VAT if I am self-employed? What is Making Tax Digital for VAT? Pensions and self-employment How do I repay my student loan if I am self-employed? Introduction to enquiries
Pension jargon buster Approaching retirement What is income? How do I work out my tax? What income is taxable? What tax allowances am I entitled to? What tax rates apply to me? How is my tax collected? How do I check my coding notice? Tax code problems on retirement What should I do if I have not paid enough tax? What tax do I pay on savings and dividend income? How do I claim any tax back? Do I need to complete a tax return? What National Insurance do I pay after retirement? What happens if I retire abroad? What is the tax position when I take money from my pension flexibly? How do I cash in my small pension? What tax do I pay on my state pension lump sum? What is state pension deferral? Pensions paid on leaving the armed forces
Taxes on death: overview Dealing with the deceased's own tax affairs Tax on income and gains after death Death of a spouse or civil partner Joint property on death Pension and life assurance policies on death Income from a deceased's person's estate Inheritance tax reliefs and exemptions State benefits on death Getting help with bereavement and inheritance tax Bereavement jargon buster
