Skip to main content
Updated on 16 November 2026

Timely tax payments: looking at the planned changes to Income Tax Self Assessment payments

Blog Post

The government has published the outcome of its consultation on bringing forward payments of income tax due under Self Assessment. The updated proposals will mean significant changes to how millions of taxpayers pay their tax under Self Assessment, with earlier and more frequent payments due to start from April 2029. Here, we look at the changes that have been announced and the details yet to be confirmed.

An hour-glass emptying, sitting on top of the letters T-A-X
eamesBot / Shutterstock.com

Why are the payment arrangements changing? 

The government wants to bring tax payments closer to when income is earned and make payments smaller, but more frequent. It believes the current arrangements can make budgeting harder for taxpayers and increase the risk of missed payments and tax debt. It has confirmed that the changes will affect only the timing of tax payments, not the amount owed.

What are the current Self Assessment payment rules? 

Around 12 million people complete a Self Assessment tax return each year. Currently, most Self Assessment taxpayers pay their tax in January following the end of the tax year, but around 3 million people have to make instalment payments towards their next tax bill, known as ‘payments on account’. These payments are normally required if your income tax payment (together with any class 4 National Insurance contributions if self-employed) for the previous year was over £1,000, unless more than 80% of your previous year’s income tax was deducted at source. This current regime is complicated and can be difficult to understand. 

Under the current rules, payments on account are usually due in two instalments: one in January during the tax year and one in the July after it ends. Each instalment is usually half the previous year's tax bill. For example, if your total tax liability for 2025/26 was £2,000, each of your payments on account for 2026/27 would be £1,000, being 50% of £2,000. You can claim to reduce these payments if you expect to owe less tax. Once you have completed your tax return and confirmed the actual amount owed, any remaining tax is usually due the following January as a balancing payment.

This can mean that tax is paid many months after the income was received – at the extreme, the gap can be up to 22 months. 

We have more information about the current Self Assessment payment rules, including some helpful examples, in our guidance.

What changes did the government originally propose? 

At Budget 2025 the government announced its plans for ‘more timely payment for Self Assessment’ – the announcement can be found here in paragraph 4.149 of the budget ‘red book’. HMRC held a consultation in summer 2026 to gather views on ‘Timely Payments in income tax Self Assessment’ –see here.

The consultation proposed bringing payments of income tax (and class 4 National Insurance for the self employed) due under Self Assessment closer to when income is earned. Under the original proposal, from April 2029 around 2.1 million Self Assessment taxpayers with sufficient income taxed through Pay As You Earn (PAYE) would have been required to pay towards their Self Assessment bill through deductions from their wages or pension. These deductions would have been subject to the usual limit on total tax and National Insurance deductions under PAYE of 50% of that income. It was proposed that payments would initially be based on their latest Self Assessment tax return, with taxpayers able to adjust the amounts if they expected their current year’s tax bill to change. 

HMRC also sought opinions on how people in Self Assessment who have no PAYE income could pay their tax earlier through smaller, more frequent payments.

The consultation attracted 3,630 responses from taxpayers, businesses and representative organisations, including LITRG and the Chartered Institute of Taxation, of which LITRG is part. The number of responses reflects the considerable level of interest in the proposals.

LITRG’s response to the consultation

In our response to the timely payment consultation, which can be found here, we recognised that earlier, more frequent tax payments could help some taxpayers budget and avoid building up large tax bills. For people with relatively stable income, spreading payments throughout the year may be easier than having to find larger lump sums in January and July.

However, we raised concerns about the impact on taxpayers without a tax adviser or other professional support, particularly those on modest incomes or whose income may vary. We were concerned that the proposed arrangements could create particular difficulties for these people. 

We were particularly concerned about the proposal to make PAYE collection compulsory for eligible taxpayers. We highlighted that this would add complexity to an already complicated system – for example, extra PAYE tax code adjustments could make it harder for people to understand their overall tax position. Instead, we argued that taxpayers should be able to choose how they pay their Self Assessment liabilities and that paying through PAYE should be voluntary. 

We called for a straightforward and flexible system that would allow people to update their income estimates without having to calculate their revised tax liabilities themselves. We highlighted the need for an accessible alternative for those who cannot access or use online services, and for the changes to be introduced gradually, with appropriate testing and ongoing engagement with users and representative organisations.

Other important points we highlighted included the need for HMRC to promptly repay any overpaid tax and for careful consideration of the interaction of the new system with Making Tax Digital, Universal Credit and student loan repayments. 

What has the government now decided?

As part of the Budget 2026 announcement the government reconfirmed its commitment to the policy of collecting earlier, more frequent payments of Self Assessment liabilities from April 2029. HMRC have published a summary of the consultation responses (found here), which also sets out some changes to the original proposals. The most notable of these changes are: 

  • Who is affected: In-year payments will extend to all Self Assessment taxpayers liable to make payments on account, including those without PAYE income.
  • PAYE collection: PAYE deductions will no longer be compulsory. Eligible taxpayers with sufficient PAYE income will be able to choose to pay through their PAYE tax code if preferred, subject to the 50% limit referred to above. 
  • Payment method: The default payment method will be an automated payment method, such as Direct Debit. 

HMRC say payments will continue to be based on the most recently filed tax return, but taxpayers will be able to update their payments online if their circumstances change. HMRC say that more frequent payments will be required but their frequency and timing, and the detailed process for updating forecasts, remain to be decided.

In preparation for the transition to the new payment arrangements, HMRC will say they will introduce new digital tools from 2028 to help people estimate the tax they owe, see how much they have paid towards it, and make voluntary advance payments.

Our reaction to the revised proposals

We are pleased that HMRC have listened to concerns raised during the consultation process and made changes to their initial proposals. 

We particularly welcome the decision to make payment of Self Assessment liabilities via PAYE optional rather than compulsory, with automated payments directly to HMRC, such as Direct Debit, becoming the default. This gives people greater control over how they pay their tax and avoids some of the complications we identified with compulsory PAYE collection. Direct payments also offer greater scope to build flexibility into the new system.  

We also welcome HMRC’s commitment to continue working with stakeholders, including LITRG, as detailed arrangements are developed, and we look forward to receiving the further details which HMRC say will be published next year. Getting the details right will be crucial to making the new system work in practice.  

Our ongoing concerns

Making PAYE optional does not, on its own, resolve all our concerns. Bringing payments forward could still create difficulties for taxpayers in a variety of ways, in particular for people on low or fluctuating incomes. 

HMRC recognise that the arrangements must be fair, flexible and reflect taxpayers’ different circumstances, including variable or unpredictable income. They have left important design questions open and have committed to further work with stakeholders. This is welcome, but the details will determine whether the new system provides sufficient flexibility to make it practical for all Self Assessment taxpayers.

Below, we consider the practical issues that HMRC will need to address as they develop the new arrangements.

Transitioning to the new payment system 

The transition year, 2029/30, will need careful planning. Under the existing rules, some taxpayers will still have to make their second payment on account for 2028/29 on 31 July 2029, followed by any balancing payment on 31 January 2030. The new system will apply from April 2029 so those taxpayers may find that they are making payments towards their 2029/20 tax bill in the same period. 

This overlap could put extra pressure on household and business finances. Taxpayers may also find it difficult to understand which tax year each payment relates to.

HMRC recognise that taxpayers need sufficient time to prepare for the changes and say have committed to providing further information and support before they are implemented. We understand that the new digital tools which will be available from 2028 will help taxpayers prepare and make voluntary pre-payments if they wish to reduce the impact of the transition, but the detailed arrangements remain to be developed. Support will need to be provided well in advance so that taxpayers can understand what they will need to pay and budget accordingly.

Dealing with irregular or fluctuating income

Moving away from compulsory PAYE collection creates more scope for flexibility, and we are reassured that HMRC recognise that the new system needs to “reflect the realities of self-employment”. However, the practical arrangements for people with seasonal or fluctuating income remain important details to resolve.

More frequent payments may help some people manage their finances, but equal instalments throughout the year will not necessarily work for those whose income is uneven. For example, someone whose business income arises mainly around Christmas could be asked to pay tax early in the year before receiving that income and before knowing how their business will perform. 

In contrast, under the current system the first instalment is due in January towards the end of the tax year. By this point, the taxpayer may have a better idea of their overall income and profits for that tax year and may already have received much of their income. 

It is also important to distinguish between someone whose income has decreased and someone whose income has remained steady but who is temporarily struggling with their cashflow. Where income falls, people should be able to update their estimates promptly so that payments reflect their revised liability. Where the overall liability is unchanged but income is seasonal or receipts are delayed, we believe HMRC should offer payment schedules that take account of when money is available, rather than requiring equal instalments throughout the year.

Earlier payments may create unnecessary financial pressure

Even where income is relatively stable, bringing payment dates forward could create financial pressure for people facing unexpected expenses or changes in their personal circumstances. Someone who can currently manage their tax bill through two larger payments may struggle if they are required to make payments more frequently if they have limited financial flexibility. 

Bringing payment dates forward does not address the underlying reasons why some people struggle to pay. Having taxable income or profits does not necessarily mean cash is immediately available to pay the tax. Earlier payment demands could therefore lead people to borrow, replacing tax debt with another form of debt.

HMRC must ensure there is a straightforward way for taxpayers to request a temporary deferral or an affordable payment plan when they are struggling to pay. There should be clear information about any interest or other consequences of late or missed payments. The aim should be to avoid pushing people towards borrowing simply to meet an earlier tax payment date.  

HMRC have left the frequency and timing of payments open for further work with stakeholders. It will be important that the arrangements are flexible enough to reflect different financial circumstances, and that any penalties and interest charges for missed or late payments are fair and proportionate. 

Making adjustments to the payment amounts

The new digital tools promised from 2028 will let people estimate their tax bill, track payments against the amount they expect to owe and make voluntary advance payments. HMRC have also identified that the method for taxpayers to update figures when their income changes is an area for further design. The practical question is whether people will be able to use these services easily to keep their payments in line with their income, and what arrangements will be available for those who cannot access or use digital services.

We will continue to work with HMRC as practical arrangements are developed. We will emphasise that the tools must be accessible and straightforward to use, as people should not need tax expertise to understand how and when to update their income details in order to adjust their payments. HMRC should calculate the revised payments and clearly explain how they have been worked out – this will be particularly important for people without a tax adviser or other professional support. 

Another unresolved question is whether penalties or interest will apply where a taxpayer reduces their payments based on a reasonable estimate of their tax liability but later finds they owe more than expected. We consider this further in the safeguards section below.

We are also concerned about the potential use of quarterly updates submitted under the Making Tax Digital for Income Tax rules to calculate tax payments. Quarterly updates are not tax returns and may not give an accurate picture of taxable profits. Taxpayers should not be expected to pay tax on the basis of information that does not accurately reflect their final taxable amounts.

Interaction with Universal Credit and other means-tested benefits 

Changing when tax is paid could affect the income figure used to calculate Universal Credit, and therefore how much someone receives and when. It could also affect access to other help that depends on receiving Universal Credit. HMRC will need to consider these interactions carefully as the proposals are developed.

It is important that HMRC work with the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) to understand these interactions before the new arrangements are introduced, to ensure that taxpayers are not inadvertently worse off or facing additional administrative burdens.

This is particularly relevant to people on low incomes, who may have little financial flexibility to absorb unexpected changes in either their tax payments or benefit awards.

Safeguards and support 

HMRC have committed to further work with stakeholders on safeguards and flexibility for taxpayers facing financial difficulty, as well as the approach to penalties and interest. The details will be crucial to ensuring that earlier payments do not create unfair pressure on people who are trying to comply.

Taxpayers must have a clear way to challenge any incorrect information used by HMRC to work out their payments. This will be particularly important if HMRC use information supplied by other organisations, such as banks, to estimate tax bills or check the payments due under the new system.

Where too much tax has been collected, overpayments should be identified and repaid without unnecessary delay, rather than automatically being carried forward against future payments. It would be unfair for taxpayers to have to wait unnecessarily for money that they have paid in advance, particularly where this causes pressure on their household or business finances.

We also take the view that there should also be appropriate protection from penalties and interest where taxpayers have made reasonable estimates but their circumstances subsequently change. 

Looking ahead 

We support the government’s objective of helping taxpayers manage their tax liabilities and reducing the build-up of tax debt. However, bringing tax payments forward will not necessarily make them easier for everyone to afford. 

The real test will be whether the new arrangements recognise the different circumstances of taxpayers by allowing them to adjust payments when their income falls, arrange an affordable payment schedule when money is tight, and get errors and overpayments put right promptly. These protections will be particularly important for people on low or fluctuating incomes, who may have little room to absorb unexpected payment demands.

We will continue to raise our concerns and press for a system that is flexible, accessible and fair as the detailed arrangements are developed. 

We would love to hear what you think about this subject – you can share your comments below.

Please note all comments are moderated in line with our comment guidelines, so there might be a short delay before your comment is published if it meets the guidelines.

Sarah Weston 
Technical officer

Comment guidelines

Add new comment

Back to top